Skip to content

Pittsburgh Theological Seminary

Grounded in Faith, Formed in Community

Menu
  • Home
  • Contact Us
Menu

Church Leadership Lessons from the Super Bowl

Posted on February 5, 2015March 9, 2021 by ptsblog
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

I have to admit that I was disappointed by the ending of the Super Bowl. Not only did I want the Patriots to lose, but I have become a Seahawks fan the last two years. They show the kind of energy and resilience that I wish my own team (the Pittsburgh Steelers) would find.

The big question of the game has been the play call that ended the game with a Seahawk interception on the goal line. Why didn’t the Seahawks hand the ball off to Marshawn Lynch and let him do the work that earned him the nickname Beast Mode? That question has been all over the TV and the radio. It has dominated social media. Deion Sanders called it the worst play call in Super Bowl history.

Coach Pete Carroll has attempted to explain the logic of the play call. He was reacting to what the Patriots were doing and trying to conserve the clock. Carroll has also taken the blame for losing the game. Many analysts and commentators seem to have lowered their opinion of Coach Carroll. I personally cannot defend the call. I would have given the ball to Lynch. But I am having the opposite reaction to Pete Carroll as I am watching him handle the situation. My opinion of him is going up. I think he is doing three things that many leaders fail to do. He made a decision, stood by that decision, and took the blame when that decision did not work out.

First, Pete Carroll made the call. He read the situation, saw an option, and made the decision. It may sound foolish, but you cannot be a leader if you don’t lead. Carroll was decisive when it counted.

Second, Pete Carroll stood by the decision. He admits that it did not work out but he still stands by what he saw and why he made the decision in the moment. It is easy to judge a decision after you know the results. Leaders have to make calls before they know the outcome.

Finally, Pete Carroll took the blame for the loss. He is not blaming other people. He is taking the shots so that his team does not have to. He is shouldering the blame and keeping the brunt of it from hitting his young players.

Maybe it was the wrong call, but the way Pete Carroll is handling this is showing exactly why the Seahawks have one championship win and two championship appearances. It is this kind of leadership that helped the Seahawks mount one of the greatest comebacks in NFL playoff history against the Packers to get to this year’s Super Bowl.

Perhaps it is a lack of this kind of leadership that is crushing many of our churches in Pennsylvania and across the US. Many pastors and church leaders don’t make decisions, don’t stand firm in their decisions or convictions, and pass blame when they lose. Pastors and elders are paralyzed by fear and will not make any decisions. Churches stay the same for years and years even though they desperately need to try new things. When a decision is made, church leaders are not resilient enough to stick with those decisions when the going gets tough and others start to question the decision. And when an idea fails, church leadership is often quick to blame others rather than shoulder the blame themselves. In fact, many church leaders don’t experience failure because they aren’t trying anything that might fail.

The mainline church has been in maintenance mode for a while. We have tried to keep our churches looking like and functioning like the church of the 1950s. While we are holding still, the world is moving at a pace unequalled in history. The church leadership of tomorrow will require more action, more experimentation, and more failure than ever before. Only that kind of leadership will produce churches of Super Bowl faithfulness.

People will be questioning that play call for a long time, but I have a feeling that Pete Carroll will redeem himself sooner rather than later. I just hope that more pastors and church leaders can learn to lead like that soon.

 

Jordan Rimmer ’12 is the pastor of Westminster Presbyterian Church in New Brighton, Pa. He is a husband and father of four children. Jordan earned a Master of Divinity (MDiv) degree from Pittsburgh Theological Seminary and is currently earning his Doctor of Ministry degree. He blogs at jordanrimmer.com. You can also download his sermons on ITunes or at http://jordanrimmer.podbean.com.

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Email
  • Twitter

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Founded in 1794, Pittsburgh Theological Seminary is a graduate theological school of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), offering master's and doctor of ministry degrees as well as certificate programs. Participating in God's ongoing mission in the world, Pittsburgh Seminary is a community of Christ joining in the Spirit's work of forming and equipping people for ministries familiar and yet to unfold and communities present and yet to be gathered.

Recent Posts

  • Lives of Faith and Service: Distinguished Alums of 2025
  • How Do I Help Someone Struggling With Their Faith?
  • Who Is My Neighbor? – The Rev. Dr. MaryAnn Rennie on Place, History, and Church “for” Community
  • Am I Preaching a Genuine Word?
  • Who Is My Neighbor? The Rev. Kathryn Lester-Bacon on Neighbor, Change, and Mutual Responsibility

Categories

  • Book Recommendations
  • Church Planting
  • Counseling
  • Inside the PTS Curriculum
  • Ministry
  • People of PTS
  • Protestant Spirituality
  • Seminary and Programs
  • Sermon Writing Tips
  • Social Work
  • Theological Reflection
  • Uncategorized
  • Who Is My Neighbor?

Archives

Tags

Bible study Black History Month Call to ministry Christian spirituality church planting church planting for new communities church planting in pennsylvania Communion elements community Community worship doctor of ministry education faith and politics fasting Festivals and holy days Good Samaritan Lent master of divinity mdiv alumni mdiv program mdiv program and social work MDiv program Pittsburgh ministry Ministry conferences and events Mission reflections mission trip pastoral care pastoral counseling Pastoral vocation PCUSA Seminary community seminary experience Seminary experiences sermon writing tips Social justice Spiritual journeys St. Patrick theological education theology and social work Urban ministry Volunteering Women in ministry world mission World Mission Initiative Youth ministry

Top Posts and Pages

  • Sermon Tips: Preaching without Notes
    Sermon Tips: Preaching without Notes
  • A Day in the Life: Undergraduate Fellowship Program
    A Day in the Life: Undergraduate Fellowship Program
  • Why does God hate me?
    Why does God hate me?
  • The "L" Word
    The "L" Word
  • A poem about hands
    A poem about hands
  • Call to the Service
    Call to the Service
  • Gamergate: The Invisible Scandal Impacting Your Ministry
    Gamergate: The Invisible Scandal Impacting Your Ministry
  • Coping with Grief During the Holidays
    Coping with Grief During the Holidays
  • Would Thomas Merton Delete His Facebook Account?
    Would Thomas Merton Delete His Facebook Account?
  • Mother’s Day: It’s Complicated
    Mother’s Day: It’s Complicated

Subscribe to Blog via E-mail

Enter your e-mail address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by e-mail.

© 2025 Pittsburgh Theological Seminary | Powered by Superbs Personal Blog theme