Skip to content

Pittsburgh Theological Seminary

Preparing for Ministry in the Way of Jesus

Menu
  • Home
  • Contact Us
Menu

Christic Manhood? Masculine Christianity?

Posted on February 9, 2012April 7, 2021 by ptsblog
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

“God has chosen to liken Himself to a female and we are the fruit of His womb.”
– John Calvin

I recently came across a post by one of my favorite bloggers Rachel Held Evans, entitled “God is Not Ashamed, Our Brothers Speak Out.” This post burgeoned from a previous post where Evans asked Brothers in Christ to respond to views expressed by popular evangelical pastor John Piper, who spoke on the importance of maintaining what he calls a “masculine Christianity,” arguing that “God has given Christianity a masculine feel.” For the full breadth of John Piper’s comments click here. 

This pastor is from my hometown of Minneapolis. I don’t mention him by name to disparage him in any way. I have read a handful of his books and have been incredibly blessed as a result. I know him to be a man of deep faith. That is what makes his comments so troubling and disheartening to a Korean American woman in seminary, preparing to go into full time ministry. Admittedly, I don’t know entirely what to do with Piper’s remarks and others in the collective Body of Christ who share his views. However, it does remind me just how grateful I am to be in a community that does not merely tolerate me, but embraces me. This community at PTS has affirmed my call, encouraged me along the way and continues to foster my development as pastor-theologian.

I have heard over and over in this place that the Church needs me, a woman, and would be blessed by my service to the Church through leadership. Daunting as it may be to hear that at times, it is also rather comforting to hear such welcoming words. The idea that I am welcomed and needed lines up with what God has made known to me by way of call. At the end of the day, the Church is the beautiful bride of Christ. It belongs to Christ! I understand my call is not actually about me. However, through me, a Korean American female, Christ is proclaimed and Christ is revealed. And so, while I face some uncertainty in what lies ahead in the coming months as I wrap up my time here, I trust that God has a plan and a place for the gifts that have been given to me by the Holy Spirit, to participate in the work of Christ in this world in all my ‘femininity.’

J.R. Daniel Kirk, a seminary professor, is one of our Brothers in Christ who took Evan’s challenge. I will leave you with his comments related to John Piper’s remarks. I pray that you find encouragement and edification through his thoughtful insight.

“ …In what is the clearest connection of God to human gender, perhaps the only clear and intentional such connection in all of scripture, it is both male and female, together, who mirror God to the world. This means that a ‘masculine’ church or a church with a ‘masculine feel’ is inherently lacking in its ability to reflect the image of God to the world.”

“According to the economy of the world, with its measures of greatness, to be the twelve is to be exemplary, in the place to lead, to exclude others from leadership, to stand close to Jesus and guard the gates of who else can draw near. And to the extent that we look to Jesus’ selection of them, and the apparent marginalization of the women, as paradigmatic for male leadership in the church, we show ourselves to be people whose minds have not yet been transformed by the very story to which we are appealing.”

“The gospel of the cross overturns such understandings of insider standing, power, and status. It rebukes our natural tendency to affirm as eligible leaders only those who are like the original insiders. When we use the Twelve as a weapon for fending off women from church leadership we align ourselves with the misapprehending disciples rather than the gospel proclaiming Christ.”

 

Melanie is a senior MDiv student at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary.

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Email
  • Twitter

Founded in 1794, Pittsburgh Theological Seminary is a graduate theological school of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), offering master's and doctor of ministry degrees as well as certificate programs. Participating in God's ongoing mission in the world, Pittsburgh Seminary is a community of Christ joining in the Spirit's work of forming and equipping people for ministries familiar and yet to unfold and communities present and yet to be gathered.

Recent Posts

  • Remembering Elizabeth Rose Vates
  • Praying with Someone Experiencing Depression
  • Women’s History at PTS: Lee Anna Starr
  • Nurturing Connection in the Classroom
  • Learning at the US/Mexico Border

Categories

  • Church Planting
  • Counseling
  • Inside the PTS Curriculum
  • Ministry
  • People of PTS
  • Protestant Spirituality
  • Seminary and Programs
  • Sermon Writing Tips
  • Social Work
  • Theological Reflection

Archives

My Tweets

Tags

#BlackLivesMatter #BlueLivesMatter Bible study Call to ministry Christian spirituality church planting church planting for new communities church planting in pennsylvania Communion elements Community worship cross-cultural education doctor of ministry education faith and politics fasting Festivals and holy days Fred Rogers Lent master of divinity mdiv alumni mdiv program mdiv program and social work MDiv program Pittsburgh ministry Ministry conferences and events Mission reflections mission trip Mister Rogers' Neighborhood pastoral counseling Pastoral vocation Seminary community seminary experience Seminary experiences sermon writing tips Social justice Spiritual journeys St. Patrick's Day theological education theology and social work Urban ministry Volunteering Women in ministry world mission World Mission Initiative Youth ministry

Top Posts and Pages

  • Why does God hate me?
    Why does God hate me?
  • Praying with People Grieving Loss from Suicide
    Praying with People Grieving Loss from Suicide
  • Seminary or Divinity School: What's the Difference?
    Seminary or Divinity School: What's the Difference?
  • Praying with Someone Experiencing Depression
    Praying with Someone Experiencing Depression
  • What's the Difference Between a DMin and a PhD?
    What's the Difference Between a DMin and a PhD?
  • Why I am Not Doing Intinction Anymore
    Why I am Not Doing Intinction Anymore
  • "Risen" Movie Review
    "Risen" Movie Review
  • Faculty Book Recommendations
    Faculty Book Recommendations
  • Doctors and Pastors Serving Together to Counsel End of Life Patients
    Doctors and Pastors Serving Together to Counsel End of Life Patients
  • A Mission Reflection: What is God Calling You to Remain Faithful In?
    A Mission Reflection: What is God Calling You to Remain Faithful In?

Subscribe to Blog via E-mail

Enter your e-mail address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by e-mail.

© 2022 Pittsburgh Theological Seminary | Powered by Superbs Personal Blog theme
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.